an Eldis Resource
Social inequality and HIV-testing: comparing home- and clinic-based testing in rural Malawi
Can moving HIV testing out of clinics make the testing process more equitable between different social groups?
Authors:
A. Weinreb; G. Stecklov
Publisher:
Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research, 2009
The plan to increase HIV testing is a cornerstone of the international health strategy against the HIV/AIDS epidemic, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa. Using material form ongoing demographic research project conducted in three rural areas of Malawi, this paper highlights a problematic aspect of that plan: the reliance on clinic- rather than home-based testing. It asks if home-based opt-in testing is the answer to contemporary testing problems?
The paper demonstrates the substantial differences in socio-demographic and economic profiles between those who report having ever had a clinic-based HIV test, and those who report never having had one. In this context, it reveals that those who have had a clinic-based HIV test tend to be wealthier, more educated, and less likely to be currently married.
The paper concludes that there are strong indications that home-based Voluntary Counseling and Testing (VCT) can equalize access to testing across socioeconomic strata, marital status, or any other social characteristics that typically affect clinic use, namely:
- in addition to dramatically increasing HIV-testing prevalence, home-based testing is also associated with marked reductions in inequalities in the profile of testees
- removing the variation in social characteristics from HIV testing is a crucial first step to reducing health-systems' inequitable practices
- it is also a crucial first step in stopping such systems from re-producing contemporary inequalities by characterising differential future patterns of infection and mortality
- it is the only way to enact a testing policy which takes advantage of the fact that the poor and ill-educated, while less likely to come to clinics, are no less willing to have an HIV test





