Jump to content

Can developing countries use taxation to reduce inequality?

Posted: 22 Sep 2015
Bruno Martorano outlines how Latin American tax policies have been successful in tackling the problem of income equality within the region.

Latin American countries have recorded important results in terms of inequality reduction during the last decade. Yet, an ignored aspect of their success is the growing emphasis placed on tax policy and the contribution of taxation in promoting an equitable distribution of income.

The region was previously influenced by neoliberal developments in tax design which saw greater emphasis on efficiency, horizontal equity and revenue adequacy (i.e. ensuring a sufficient amount of revenue is generated). As a result, governments tried to simplify and rationalize tax structures as well as to widen the tax base. In particular, VAT and other consumption taxes replaced trade taxes considered harmful in terms of domestic and international allocation of resources. In addition, personal and corporate income taxes were lowered in order to reduce as much as possible the negative consequences on labour supply and investments.

Nonetheless – contrary to the intended aims – tax policy failed to improve economic growth, contributing to macroeconomic instability and fuelling income inequality. These, together with increasing frustration with the poor results of the Washington Consensus policies and the process of democratic consolidation, saw the election success of left-wing parties in Latin America. Indeed the new left governments have followed a different strategy, focusing on more equitable growth – with taxation back to its original role of promoting development, assuring macroeconomic stabilization as well as reducing inequality.

In particular, Latin American governments have tried to mobilize revenue with a new emphasis placed on progressivity in tax design:
  • First, the vast majority of them have implemented important administrative reforms switching toward a functional rationalization of their administrative structures – i.e. focusing on tax activities (tax collection, data management etc.) – adopting a Semi-Autonomous Revenue Authorities model and establishing large taxpayer units (for those with larger receipts to pay)
  • They have enlarged their tax base, reducing numbers of exemptions and removing several forms of deductions
  • Furthermore, governments have used several unorthodox forms of taxation such as simplified tax regimes and taxes on financial transactions
  • Finally, many countries have reformed their direct tax system (especially in the late 2000s).

As a result, Vito Tanzi, former IMF Director of Fiscal Affairs explains that ‘with a closer look, it could be maintained that the changes that took place over the years, in the tax systems of many Latin American countries, have made those tax systems far better than they had been in the past in some aspects’.

These reforms have generated important consequences in terms of revenue mobilization as well as income distribution. Indeed, research colleagues and I have seen that recent tax policy changes in Latin America together with favourable external conditions have promoted an increase of the tax/GDP ratio. We have also shown that greater reliance on direct taxes and a reduction in indirect taxes has promoted the redistributive role of taxation - with the Gini coefficient of the distribution of household income improving on average by 0.4-0.8 points. The redistributive role of direct taxes was also confirmed by Lustig and colleagues in a recent work.

The Uruguayan Tax Reform of 2007, which introduced a dual tax system combining a new progressive labour income tax and a flat capital income tax, is further evidence of the possibility of harvesting more revenues whilst also enhancing the redistribution of resources. Figure 1 highlights the rise in revenue in the country since 2007, whilst recent research of mine on the Uruguayan model shows that the new tax on labour income has lowered inequality by two Gini points (Figure 2).

Figures 1 and 2

To conclude, the Latin American story provides important lessons for middle-income countries i.e. that taxation can contribute to reducing inequality. However it has real lessons for developing contexts too.

For instance:

  • Improving tax administration – reducing tax evasion and increasing tax compliance
  • Increasing the contribution of wealth and income taxes
  • Ensuring that increases in taxes meet peoples’ expectations in terms of the quantity and quality of public services.
These are general recommendations and would need to be adapted to the specific conditions of each country.

References and recommended reading

Income inequality in Latin America: recent decline and prospects for its further reduction
G.A. Cornia / Dipartimento di Scienze Economiche, Universita' degli Studi di Firenze 2014
 The paper reviews the extent of the income inequality decline which has taken place in Latin America over 2002-10 which reduced the regional Gini index to the level of the early 1980s. The paper then focuses on the factors which...
A new fiscal pact, tax policy changes and income inequality: Latin America during the last decade
G.A. Cornia; J.C. Gómez-Sabaini; B. Martorano / United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research 2011
The paper analyses the changes in tax policy, tax/GDP ratios, tax incidence and income inequality which have taken place in Latin America during the last decade against the background of the changes observed in these variables during ...
The Impact of Uruguay’s 2007 Tax Reform on Equity and Efficiency
B. Martorano / Dipartimento di Scienze Economiche, Universita' degli Studi di Firenze 2012
In 2007, the Uruguayan government implemented a new tax reform which introduced a new progressive labour income tax, a flat capital income tax, and reduced some indirect taxes, with the objective of improving fiscal bal...
Tax Reform In Latin America: A long term assessment
V. Tanzi / CEPAL - ECLAC Database 2013
This paper is a transcript of a talk given by the author at the 25th Regional Seminar on Fiscal Policy - Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC). Here he seeks to address three questions: ...
The impact of taxes and social spending on inequality and poverty in Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Mexico, Peru, and Uruguay: an overview
N. Lustig / Commitment to Equity 2013
How much redistribution and poverty reduction is being accomplished in Latin America through social spending and taxes? Standard fiscal incidence analyses applied to Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Mexico, Peru, and Uruguay yield the foll...
From volatility to stabilization: cyclicality of fiscal policy in Latin America over the last decades
B. Martorano / Dipartimento di Scienze Economiche, Universita' degli Studi di Firenze 2014
Latin American countries experienced important changes over the last decade. The implementation of fiscal reforms, public debt reduction and the high level of accumulated reserves gave them more policy space than in the past. As a res...
Designing performance: the semi-revenue authority model in African and Latin America
R. Taliercio / World Bank 2004
The paper analyzes a subset of semi-autonomous revenue authorities (ARAs) from both Africa and Latin America. The cases (Kenya, Mexico, Peru, South Africa, Uganda and Venezuela) were selected based on three criteria: (1) the importanc...

Latest Documents

A stitch in time: preventive diplomacy and the Lake Malawi dispute
A. Lalbahadur / South African Institute of International Affairs 2016
A low-intensity dispute between Malawi and Tanzania threatens regional peace as the two countries contest the demarcation of their national boundaries at Lake Malawi. This long-standing dispute became more urgent when in 2011 ...
UNAMID police and the protection of civilians in Darfur
F.K. Aubyn / Kofi Annan International Peace Keeping Training Centre 2016
This Policy Brief reflects on the Protection of Civilian (PoC) strategies of UNAMID Police and some of the challenges hindering their effective implementation in Darfur. It argues that for PoC to be successful, UNAMID Police s...
Conflict trends issue 1, 2016
African Centre for Constructive Resolution of Disputes 2016
The Great Lakes Project (GLP) constitutes one such effort in promoting a regionally focused programme for sustainable peace. Over the past three years, the GLP has sought to channel the comparative advantages of each partner into...
Managing oil resources in the absence of sound democratic processes
H. Eriksson; B. Hagstromer / Nordic Africa Institute / Nordiska Afrikainstitutet, Uppsala 2005
Chad is currently undergoing two processes of significant importance for its future development - political democratisation and transformation into an oil economy. A strong increase of financial resources in a poor country should norm...
Why has power sharing not prevented conflict in Lebanaon?
S. Makdisi (ed); M. Marktanner (ed) / American University of Beirut 2008
This paper examines Lebanon’s model of consociational democracy, a political arrangement in which diverse ethnic groups, share power according to an agreed formula or mechanism. Consociationalism, as opposed to a simple majority...

Assessing the quality of research can be a tricky business.

Our guide offers some tools and tips.